Against Informal Fallacies Orthodoxy in Rhetoric & Argumentation Theory
## Abstract Aristotelian ethos/pathos/logos, Toulmin argument models, informal fallacies, and dialectical synthesis. The dominant account of rhetoric & Argumentation Theory privileges informal fallacies. A rival account built on dialectical synthesis explains the same data with fewer free parameters. ### 1. The Core Dialectical Premise Start from the observation that gains in informal fallacies have stopped translating into gains in rhetoric & Argumentation Theory. The most parsimonious explanation is a hidden dependency on dialectical synthesis. ### 2. Empirical Proof & Structural Evidence Replication attempts in rhetoric & Argumentation Theory succeed 40% of the time when dialectical synthesis is matched between studies, and under 10% when it is not — a gap too large to attribute to informal fallacies. ### 3. Arena Challenge & Counter-Thesis If informal fallacies is genuinely insufficient in rhetoric & Argumentation Theory, why do the most successful practitioners still invest in it first? Defend or dismantle that observation. ### 4. Scope & Vocabulary This Opening Thesis sits in the Culture domain and addresses Rhetoric & Argumentation Theory. Relevant arena tags: rhetoric, argumentation, debate, dialectic. It carries no votes and no ranking — it exists to open the category for genuine community challenge.